Skip to main content

Political Representation – Best Practices and Brilliant Failures

 


On Tuesday March 19 2024, the alliance Politica, a collaboration between four organisations with the aim to expand political representation of women in all their diversity in the Netherlands, organised an online session in the NGO CSW68 Forum called: ‘Making Political Participation Work Worldwide!’ In the session we discussed the representation of women in the political systems of the Netherlands, Sweden, Spain and Mexico. During a lively session we learned about best practices and brilliant failures in these countries, such as a gender quota.

The Netherlands needs more attention for women role models

If you don't have a seat at the table, there's someone sitting in your chair,” according to Devika Partiman, founder and director of Stem op een Vrouw (Vote for a Woman). Women are still underrepresented in Dutch politics. This applies to all political levels, from municipal councils to the national parliament. But why? Devika introduced the results of Politica’s latest research on barriers that women face to become, to be and to stay politically active. These barriers can be divided in social-cultural barriers (think about stereotypes), political barriers (think about working conditions and violence faced by women in politics) and knowledge and information barriers (think about the lack of role models or a relevant network). She stressed the importance of having role models in politics: “In the Netherlands when people speak about political role models, only the first [usually a man] in something is mentioned. Never who came after. We try to promote ‘other first’ role models, so more people can recognize themselves and be inspired." Read more about the research here.

Sweden sees successful voluntary gender quota but there are gaps

Following on Devika’s call for more role models, Christina Alnevall from the Swedish Gender Equality Agency shares that increased representation of women in politics indeed “also serves as a powerful form of role model, inspiring other women and girls to engage in politics.” She explains that political representation of women in all their diversity is important for multiple reasons: “It reflects society's diversity and thereby builds trust and legitimacy. By increasing the representation of women in politics, democracies become more inclusive. Furthermore, studies have shown that greater gender diversity in political decision-making bodies leads to improved policy outcomes."

Sweden is known to have a high number of women that are politically active. Almost all political parties have taken specific measures to achieve this. One successful practice has been the implementation of a voluntary gender quota by political parties for their candidate lists, explained Christina Alnevall from the Swedish Gender Equality Agency. However, she emphasizes that there is still a lack of representation of young women. In addition, young women tend to drop out of politics earlier in Sweden. Attitudes and aggression towards women in politics play an important role. Christina therefore concludes: “We need to focus on representation, conditions, attitudes. We must improve efforts against violence against female politicians”.  

Spain’s success is not entirely due to the quota system…

For Ainhoa Novo Arbona, professor at the Political Science department at the University of Basque Country the importance of women’s political representation is a no-brainer: “It is as relevant as the participation of men. Why do we, as a society, naturally sustain this level of underrepresentation?” Her research concerns gender studies, gender representation and quota (in Spain and comparative). Women make up 40% of the Spanish Parliament. But according to Ainhoa the gender quota that Spain introduced since 2008 “hasn't been that effective. The voluntary zipper system is. Political parties now focus more on how they create the list.”

In Mexico collaborating feminists across parties have made a difference

Dapthne Cuevas from Equidad de Género (Mexico), a feminist activist with a degree in economics and government stresses that political change has to be done together. “I have dedicated my efforts to political advocacy in Mexico and Latin America, working to ensure that the feminist agenda is translated into laws and public policies promoting gender equality and women's human rights… In Mexico we've done so as feminists, across different political parties. We came together, because we had a common goal: improving political participation of all women."

The topic of online violence faced by women politicians was brought up many times, but did not get the time it required in this session. Alliance Politica plans to organize a follow-up webinar to share more experiences around addressing online violence against women in politics. Interested? Keep an eye on our social media.

We take the lessons learned about what works and what does not to increase women’s political representation home with us to continue to work on the topic of more sustainable participation of women in Dutch politics!

Written by Yara Bon, WO=MEN / Alliantie Politica

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

CSW Revitalisation conversations in the region

  Photo: Facilitation team (Liliane Nkunzimana, Lopa Banerjee, Nadia van der Linde, Ivy Koek) What do you think about when you hear countries are committed to 'revitalize' the UN Commission on the  Status of Women (CSW)? "Oh, is it dying?" is one of the responses I've gotten, as if the CSW is holding on to its last straws at the moment, in desparate need of resuscitation. The challenges ahead for the current multilateral system, as well as for many of our national governments, are huge. In order to give gender equality and the rights of all women and girls a bit more of a boost, UN Women has been encouraging countries to commit to a process to 'revitalize' the CSW. And now that this has indeed been taken on board by governments from around the world in the recent Pact for the Future, the conversation is moving to: So what does that mean? During the NGO Forum in Geneva that took place just prior to the UNECE Beijing+30 Regional Review in October 2024 I co-f...

The CSW68 is a wrap!

  Met Nederlands ambassadeur en CSW Facilitator Yoka Brandt op de foto na afloop van de CSW68 “We have reservations on the text. We don’t have instructions to proceed to adoption .” After seven days of negotiations at the UN during this year’s Commission on the Status of Women (CSW), Nigeria almost blocked the negotiated outcome document from being adopted. Almost, because after some formal and informal interventions in Conference Room 4, the Nigerian delegate, flanked by the Dutch Ambassador Yoka Brandt, added: “I now have instructions to support the adoption.” On the balcony filled with civil society as well as in the plenary room there was a clear sigh of relief followed by enthusiastic applause, hugging and photo taking. We have Agreed Conclusions ! Early negotiations As usual, the CSW negotiations process started early February with a Zero Draft , developed by UN Women and the CSW Bureau. And with input and inspiration taken from the Secretary General Report. For the EU...

CSW68 Youth Dialogue statement by Fenna Timsi

  Dutch youth representative Fenna Timsi gives her statement in the CSW68 Youth Dialogue On Thursday afternoon, 14 March 2024, the Dutch youth representative Fenna Timsi gave her statement in the CSW68 Youth Dialogue inside the UN. The reflections from several participants of this year's Youth Dialogue - the second ever as part of the CSW - were that it has much improved compared to last year. Importantly, many more of the people who were given the floor were actually young people themselves. Many of the statements were rich and relevant in content with clear and important messages for the government delegates in the other room in the UN who had started the negotiations for the outcome document. Read Fenna's statement below or see the full Youth Dialogue here (Fenna's statement is at 1:20:10). Dear all,   As the Dutch UN Youth Representative, I thank you to speak independently on behalf of young people in the Netherlands, not on behalf of the government. I spoke to many yo...